Skip to content
John KurtzCharlotte · NC

View all 47 photos →

Lake Toxaway · Lake Toxaway, NC

251 Toxaway Court

Lake Toxaway, NC · 5,005 sqft

$2,875,000

  • 3Beds
  • 5Baths
  • 5,005SqFt
  • 1991Year
  • 1Days on market

About this home

Positioned along the first ridge of Toxaway Mountain within the prestigious Lake Toxaway Estates, this extraordinary 5,000 sq ft mountain retreat blends timeless character with thoughtfully curated modern luxury. Once featured in Southern Accents as “a broad, low ramble of porches,” the fully renovated residence captures sweeping Blue Ridge Mountain views while offering exceptional privacy just minutes from Lake Toxaway Country Club and less than an hour from vibrant Asheville. Designed for both relaxed mountain living and effortless entertaining, the home features 3 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms, and a beautifully reimagined open floor plan where rustic elegance meets refined comfort. A chef’s kitchen, spa-inspired baths, expansive gathering spaces, and thoughtfully designed interiors create a warm yet elevated atmosphere throughout. Multiple porches and patios embrace the surrounding mountain scenery, while a hidden children’s bunk room and flexible recreation space add charm and versatility for hosting family and guests alike. Extensive improvements include a newly constructed 2-car garage with workshop, whole-house generator, UV water filtration system, EV wiring, and integrated smart home technology. Residents enjoy access to the exceptional lifestyle of Lake Toxaway, including scenic hiking trails, North Carolina’s largest private lake, and optional membership opportunities at Lake Toxaway Country Club based on application and availability. A rare offering designed to be enjoyed for generations to come.

Property details

Beds
3
Baths
5
SqFt
5,005
Lot
Year built
1991
Type
Single Family
Days on market
1
Garage
2
Style
Traditional
Heating
Heat Pump
Cooling
Heat Pump
Foundation
Basement, Crawl Space
Flooring
Tile, Wood
View
Mountain(s)
HOA dues
$4,085 / yr

Payment estimate

Estimated monthly payment

Includes P&I, tax, insurance, HOA

$21,500/ month

Principal & interest
$17,805
Property tax (~1.05%)
$2,515
Homeowners insurance
$838
HOA dues
$340

Down payment

$143,750 down · $2,731,250 financed

Income to qualify (28% rule)

~$921,441 / year household

A rough rule — actual qualification depends on your full debt picture, credit, and the lender. John can introduce you to lenders he trusts.

Numbers are a directional estimate. Actual monthly cost varies by lender, credit, taxes assessed at closing, and insurance carrier. This is not a loan offer or pre-approval.

Location

Begin the conversation

When you're
ready, so am I.

Whether you're quietly considering a move or simply curious about what your home might bring today, I welcome the conversation. Every relationship begins with a coffee.